Wednesday 31 October 2007

Alternative Competition Formats - Episode 1172

I am interested in alternative formats for chess competitions. And to the possible annoyance of the ACTJCL Development Squad, I sometimes try them out. Not all of them are good (some turn out to be quite horrible), and success of the Swiss format does discourage organisers from trying anything new.
One format that is new to me (but not new to millions of players) is the format I saw described in the Japanese Manga "Hikaru No Go". This is a comic concerning a teenager who is becoming a Go professional (the link will tell you more). In qualifying for the "Pro Test" they use the following method.
Players need to score 3 wins to move on to the next stage. Once you score three wins you stop playing for that round, and once you suffer three losses you go home. Players are paired randomly for each game and you can't play the same player twice (unless you must). So everyone gets at least 3 games (and 3 opponents).
Why this interests me is that it may serve as an alternative to a straight knockout, which has never taken off in chess. Played with a fast time limit (rapid 20m+10s) you could have 2 5 game sessions a day, meaning 4 sets of eliminations over a 2 day period. You could then have a final play off between the remaining players to determine the final prizes.
I can see advantages over a seeded knockout (which has too many obvious results), and a purely random one (top two players meet in rd 1), but whether this would be a popular alternative to current formats I'm not sure.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Real problem is that strong players could just play for a draw against each other and wait to draw the easier players.

Also each round could go over 12 games

Anonymous said...

Hello
http://www.heartland-appaloosas.com/ - phentermine no prescription
You will eat less and at the same time notice that you don’t feel hungry and will be able to do more exercise.
[url=http://www.heartland-appaloosas.com/]cheap phentermine online[/url]
You will eat less and at the same time notice that you don’t feel hungry and will be able to do more exercise.
phentermine cost

Adipex works by suppressing one’s appetite.

Anonymous said...

klonopin pill

Clonazepam must be used by the person it was prescribed for as it may become a habit.
[url=http://www.juniornationalcyclingassociation.org/]buy klonopin online[/url]
Klonopin - the benzo miracle Buy Klonopin (Clonazepam) online and save your money!
http://www.juniornationalcyclingassociation.org/ - klonopin clonazepam
Always remember to keep your medicine in a secured place.

Anonymous said...

Hello
order meridia

Most common adverse effects include: - Nausea - Headaches - stomach aches - flushing - dizziness - constipation - joint or muscle pain - dry mouth - increased blood pressure levels, so it is essential for a patient to be monitored when using this drug.
[url=http://www.buyrooibos.com/]meridia drug[/url]
Changes in the patient’s heart rate and blood pressure levels must be considered when deciding on dose titration.
http://www.buyrooibos.com/ - meridia no prescription
Changes in the patient’s heart rate and blood pressure levels must be considered when deciding on dose titration.

Anonymous said...

Free Drug Withdrawal Clinics Utah
vardenafil online

It is always recommended to take any medicine only after doctor’s prescription.
[url=http://www.aur-phala.com/]generic vardenafil[/url]

- Men who already taken this capsule reported of having hard core sex with great success in their sexual life.
http://www.aur-phala.com/ - generic vardenafil
Similar to other two medicines this also helps to increase flow of blood in penis.